Recent surveys show that 76% of finance leaders face high pressure to adopt artificial intelligence (AI). At the same time, they also face pressure to demonstrate return on investment (ROI) for those AI tools without having clear benchmarks for measuring payback on the investments.
New research by the American Productivity & Quality Center (APQC) changes that. This study of almost 900 organizations found that the estimated payback period for 50% of finance artificial intelligence projects falls between 5 and 10 months, with a median of 8 months. This provides a workable benchmark for CFOs to start using.

Payback is Hard to Measure
There are several reasons why payback on AI implementation is hard to measure. For one thing, it’s challenging to quantify productivity gains with a dollar amount. Avoiding labor costs for specific processes, faster reporting, shorter cycle times, and quick information access are also challenging to quantify.
Another challenge is that ROI is asymmetric; overall performance might be positive, but the payback on individual use cases within an organization can vary widely. In a recent Gartner survey, 55% of surveyed finance leaders reported clear returns from their overall AI initiatives. However, when considering individual use cases, “57% of the use cases evaluated had unclear returns,” and only 18% were described as “positive.”
Tips for Measuring ROI
CFOs should expect different timelines for ROI on different AI use cases, and factor that into their measurements. For example, Gartner’s survey found that when AI was used to improve data extraction and retrieval, it took an average of 9.3 months to deliver ROI. On the other hand, AI projects focused on scenario planning and simulations delivered ROI in an average of 13.7 months.
CFO.com recommends that calculating ROI timelines for AI projects should focus on specific use cases. Start by establishing a pre-AI baseline for the financial process that will be affected by AI implementation. Then, calculate the full cost of AI investment for that process. Then, CFOs will be able to track actual results and compare with the baseline after implementing the AI system. You can use the APQC median of 8 months ROI as a starting point for benchmarking.
Foundations for Useful AI
To realize ROI from implementing AI in finance, your company needs people trained to use the AI tools effectively and check the AI output for errors. It also requires solid data for the AI system to use. That’s hard to come by when your financial processes are mired in manual tasks or haven’t been fully digitized. Streamlining financial processes with Business Process Automation (BPA) software improves your finance processes and lays the groundwork for more successful AI use.
If you’re looking to improve company finances from the ground up in preparation for effective AI implementation, NextProcess can help. We offer real financial management solutions for mid-market and larger businesses that integrate seamlessly with existing ERPs. Contact us today to share your current process, ERP stack, and process automation goals. We’ll set up a free, interactive demo tailored to your needs so you can see how our solutions work in real time, ask questions, and see if our solutions fit your company.





